Every week we watch somewhere between forty and sixty short films that have been sent to us. Most run between ninety seconds and four minutes. The ones we publish are rarely the longest or the most technically ambitious. They are the ones that know exactly what they are doing.
A four-minute film has room for about one idea, one turn, and one ending. A twelve-minute film has room for three — and most people who send us twelve minutes have one. The extra time goes into establishing shots, repeated beats, a second musical cue that says the same thing as the first. Nothing is wrong with those shots individually. Together they dilute the thing that made the opening worth watching.
OneThe four-second decision
There is a practical reason too. On a phone, in a feed, a viewer decides within about four seconds whether to keep watching. If the first shot is a wide landscape with no subject, the decision is already made. The films that survive it usually open on a face, a hand, a sound that does not belong, or a frame that is slightly wrong in a way that makes you stay to find out why.
“Cut the first thirty seconds. Then watch it again and cut the first fifteen. The film is usually what is left.”Note pinned above the editor's desk, origin unknown
We are not arguing for shortness as a style. A ninety-second clip that is really a trailer for a longer idea is worse than an honest eight-minute piece. The argument is narrower: the length should be set by the idea, and most ideas are smaller than their makers think. If you can describe the film in one sentence without using the word “journey”, it is probably a short one.
TwoWhat we look for
Three things, in order. A subject we have not seen a hundred times this month. A sound design that was decided rather than inherited from a music library. An ending that does not explain itself. Everything else — camera, grade, aspect ratio — is craft, and craft can be learned. Those three are judgment, and judgment is what makes four minutes worth the four minutes.
ThreeOn endings
The most common note we send is not about length at all. It is about the last eight seconds: the shot that tells the viewer what to feel. Cut it. The film will end one beat earlier and be better for it, because the viewer will do the work themselves — which is the only reason to watch anything.
If you make short work and want it considered, the address is at the foot of this page. We read everything. We answer about a third of it, which is not a comment on quality; it is a comment on how many emails four editors can answer in a week.